Brown Butter Chocolate Chip
A rich, buttery cookie made with nutty brown butter and loaded with decadent chocolate chips.
Contains: WheatContains: MilkContains: EggsNot gluten-freeNot vegan
Small-batch bake shopSweet moments, made from scratch
Small-batch cookies baking every other weekend, located in the Indianapolis area. Three collections, real butter, and a whole lot of love.
The menu
Three collections to choose from
Classic Collection
The cookies that started it all.
Funfetti Sugar Cookie
A buttery, soft-baked sugar cookie bursting with colorful sprinkles for a nostalgic taste of celebration.
Contains: WheatContains: MilkContains: EggsNot gluten-freeNot vegan
Cookie Monster
A soft, vibrant blue cookie packed with Oreos, Chips Ahoy, white chocolate and milk chocolate chips.
Contains: WheatContains: MilkContains: EggsContains: SoyNot gluten-freeNot vegan
Fall Collection
Seasonal flavors, made to stand out.
Pumpkin Roll
A warmly spiced pumpkin cookie topped with a smooth, espresso cream cheese frosting and a sprinkle of cinnamon for the ultimate fall treat.
Contains: WheatContains: MilkContains: EggsNot gluten-freeNot veganContains caffeine
Salted Caramel Apple
A warm spiced cookie filled with apple pieces and topped with caramel sauce and finished with a touch of flaky sea salt.
Contains: WheatContains: MilkContains: EggsNot gluten-freeNot vegan
White Chocolate Biscoff
A rich, chewy cookie loaded with creamy white chocolate and irresistible Biscoff cookie pieces.
Contains: WheatContains: MilkContains: EggsContains: SoyNot gluten-freeNot vegan
Complete Collection
All six flavors — the whole NCC lineup.
Brown Butter Chocolate Chip
A rich, buttery cookie made with nutty brown butter and loaded with decadent chocolate chips.
Contains: WheatContains: MilkContains: EggsNot gluten-freeNot vegan
Funfetti Sugar Cookie
A buttery, soft-baked sugar cookie bursting with colorful sprinkles for a nostalgic taste of celebration.
Contains: WheatContains: MilkContains: EggsNot gluten-freeNot vegan
Cookie Monster
A soft, vibrant blue cookie packed with Oreos, Chips Ahoy, white chocolate and milk chocolate chips.
Contains: WheatContains: MilkContains: EggsContains: SoyNot gluten-freeNot vegan
Pumpkin Roll
A warmly spiced pumpkin cookie topped with a smooth, espresso cream cheese frosting and a sprinkle of cinnamon for the ultimate fall treat.
Contains: WheatContains: MilkContains: EggsNot gluten-freeNot veganContains caffeine
Salted Caramel Apple
A warm spiced cookie filled with apple pieces and topped with caramel sauce and finished with a touch of flaky sea salt.
Contains: WheatContains: MilkContains: EggsNot gluten-freeNot vegan
White Chocolate Biscoff
A rich, chewy cookie loaded with creamy white chocolate and irresistible Biscoff cookie pieces.
Contains: WheatContains: MilkContains: EggsContains: SoyNot gluten-freeNot vegan
Allergen note: All cookies are baked in a home kitchen that handles wheat, milk, eggs, soy, and tree nuts. None of our cookies are gluten-free or vegan.
Pricing$15$25$45Build your box
Simple, sweet, and shareable
Three
Pick any flavors
Half Dozen
Mix and match
Dozen
Best value
Our story
Built by best friends turned sisters.
Nia's Cookie Co. began with a simple love for baking and a desire to create something that brought people joy. Before NCC, there was TJ's Homemade Sweets — a small home-based cookie business run for about two years. The creating and sharing was a joy, but the business wasn't yet sustainable, and the demands began to outweigh the reward.
A few years later, the idea came back — but this time, with a clearer vision. Nia's Cookie Co. was created to build something intentional, sustainable, and special. What started as a love for baking has grown into a family business built around handcrafted, small-batch cookies, meaningful experiences, and the belief that something as simple as a really good cookie can make an ordinary moment feel a little sweeter.
Today, Nia's Cookie Co. is being built by best friends turned sisters Te'Nia and Alysha, with a shared goal of creating a brand that can grow into something bigger than either of us imagined — while still staying rooted in quality, creativity, and community.
— Te'Nia & Alysha, founders
Good to know
Frequently asked questions
How do I place an order?
When a cookie drop is live, simply place your order through this website before the ordering window closes.
How often do you bake?
We release fresh cookie drops every other weekend. Join our mailing list or follow us on Instagram to be the first to know when ordering opens.
Can I place a custom order?
At this time, we focus on our scheduled cookie drops.
Do you offer gluten-free or vegan cookies?
Not at this time.
Do your cookies contain allergens?
Our cookies may contain or come into contact with wheat, milk, eggs, soy, peanuts, and tree nuts. While we take care in our baking process, we cannot guarantee an allergen-free environment.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept all major credit and debit cards through our secure checkout.
Can I order through Instagram or Facebook?
No. Please order through our website so we can keep track of all orders.
Why are your cookies only available every other weekend?
We intentionally bake in small batches so every cookie is fresh, high quality, and made with care. Limiting our cookie drops allows us to focus on quality over quantity.
Do you offer catering or large orders?
At the current moment, we do not offer catering or large orders.
How should I store my cookies?
Store your cookies in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 5 days.
Order
Ready for a box of your own?
Build your box right here — pick your collection, choose your size, and reserve a pickup day. We bake it fresh.
Start your orderQuestions? Email info@niascookieco.com